Submitted by Bob Peterson

Submitted by Ed Marcuse

Two new studies involving more than 1 million US veterans suggest that updated COVID-19 vaccines continue to provide meaningful protection against severe illness.
One study, published last week in Vaccine, found that the 2025–26 vaccine reduced the risk of emergency department visits by approximately 32% and the risk of hospitalization by roughly 44%. The second study, published last week in JAMA Network Open, found that the 2025–26 Moderna vaccine offered greater protection against medically attended COVID among older adults than Pfizer’s vaccine.
In the first study, a team led by researchers from Veterans Affairs (VA) Saint Louis Health Care System analyzed data from 931,943 veterans who received a seasonal flu vaccine from September 21, 2025, to January 31, 2026. Of those, 114,911 received a COVID vaccine on the same day, while 817,032 received only the flu vaccine.
Over the course of 180 days, COVID vaccination was associated with a 31.7% reduction in COVID-related emergency department (ED) visits and a 43.6% decrease in hospitalizations. That translates to approximately seven fewer ED visits and roughly three fewer hospitalizations per 10,000 people.
While the researchers note that the absolute risk reductions were modest, the findings “quantify the benefit of vaccination in a lower-incidence season and can inform shared clinical decision making and seasonal vaccine policy,” they write.
For the second study, researchers led by a team from VA Providence Healthcare System in Rhode Island compared Moderna’s newer mRNA-1283 COVID vaccine with Pfizer/BioNTech’s mRNA COVID vaccine among US veterans aged 65 years or older to assess whether 2025–26 vaccination was associated with a lower risk of COVID infection that required medical attention.
Among the 294,499 participants, medically attended COVID occurred in 86 of 55,349 mRNA-1283 vaccine recipients (0.16%) and 672 of 239,150 Pfizer vaccine recipients (0.28%). That corresponds to a 35.9% greater relative vaccine effectiveness (VE) for the Moderna vaccine, or 10 fewer medically attended cases per 10,000 vaccinated people.
Submitted by Pam Peterson
This is a test of the National Emergency Alert System. Had there been an actual emergency, we would have failed to notify you in a timely manner, or possibly at all. We don’t have as many people here on weekends, and the last employee who understood how this shit worked was fired for refusing to replace the emergency siren with Donald Trump screaming, “I ALONE CAN FIX IT!” Please be advised that the United States is currently experiencing several dozen emergencies, none of which meet this administration’s definition of an emergency, which is something that truly inconveniences the President personally. If you are among the millions of Americans facing the loss of healthcare coverage, please remain calm. Your inability to afford lifesaving medical treatment is not an emergency. It is an exciting opportunity to explore the healing properties of bankruptcy. If you are hungry because your food assistance has been eliminated, please understand that hunger is a personal responsibility issue. The government recommends eating less, working harder, and avoiding the unnecessary luxury of having children. If the nation’s air traffic control system fails, please remain seated. Your aircraft is not in danger. It is participating in an unscheduled experiment in deregulated gravity. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy will address the situation immediately after changing out of his pajamas and consulting the former contestants of The Real Worldand Road Rules. If the banking system collapses, please do not panic. Your money is perfectly safe. We simply cannot tell you where it is, whether it still exists, or why the President’s family has suddenly purchased another piece of property in a foreign country. In the event of a nationwide power outage, please visit our website for instructions. If you cannot access our website because you have no electricity, please borrow some from a neighbor. If your neighbor also has no electricity, please chastise them for failing to achieve energy independence. If a foreign government launches a cyberattack against the United States, please allow 24 to 48 hours for the White House to determine whether the attacking nation is an enemy, an ally, or a potential investor in Trump Tower Moscow. If nuclear missiles are detected approaching American airspace, please shelter beneath a sturdy table while the President contacts Vladimir Putin to determine whether this is a misunderstanding or an exciting new business opportunity. If the emergency occurs during a presidential golf outing, please understand that the President cannot be disturbed unless the emergency involves his personal property, the stock market, Natalie Harp, or a television personality saying something nice about him. If you are experiencing a natural disaster in a blue state, federal assistance will be provided once your governor apologizes for the recent election results and agrees to rename at least three city streets after Donald Trump. If you are experiencing a natural disaster in a red state, please remain patient while the President flies overhead, throws several thousand commemorative MAGA hats and paper towels out of Air Force One, and declares the recovery a tremendous success. If you are experiencing a deadly pandemic, please consult the Secretary of Health and Human Services, who is currently investigating whether germs are real and whether measles can be cured by drinking raw milk while swimming in raw sewage. If you are experiencing civil unrest, please remain indoors while the administration determines whether the people outside are exercising their constitutional rights or require immediate deportation to a country they’ve never visited. If the President declares martial law, please do not be alarmed. Your constitutional rights have not been suspended. They have been temporarily relocated to an undisclosed facility pending administrative review. If you are concerned about government corruption, please contact the Department of Justice. Your complaint will be forwarded to the appropriate official, who will then determine whether you need to be investigated. If you believe the President is lying about an emergency, please consult the White House website, where the President’s statements are independently verified by the President. IMPORTANT NOTICE REGARDING GOVERNMENT TRANSPARENCY In the interest of national security, the administration has adopted a revised emergency classification system. A catastrophe is now a temporary inconvenience. A humanitarian crisis is now a border security achievement. A government shutdown is now a historic reduction in unnecessary services. A preventable death is now an unfortunate statistical development. A constitutional crisis is now a bold exercise of executive leadership. And a presidential lie is now an official government statement. Please be advised that emergency alerts will no longer be issued for disasters caused by government policy. These are considered successful implementation outcomes. If the President personally causes a national emergency, the emergency will be renamed THE GREATEST EMERGENCY IN AMERICAN HISTORY, and commemorative merchandise will be available for purchase before the first ambulance arrives. If you require immediate assistance, please call us. You can press 1 for English, 2 for Spanish, or 3 to hear a prerecorded message explaining why everything is Joe Biden’s fault. If you are calling from Canada, please tell us how your healthcare system works. If you are calling from Greenland, please remain on the line. The President would like to make you an offer you literally can’t refuse. THIS CONCLUDES OUR TEST OF THE NATIONAL EMERGENCY ALERT SYSTEM. Had this been an actual emergency, you would have received no warning, followed by a presidential announcement that everything was under control, followed by a second announcement blaming Democrats, followed by a third announcement declaring victory, followed by a fourth announcement denying that the emergency ever occurred. Three days later, the President would announce that nobody could have predicted the disaster, despite having received 47 intelligence briefings, 19 written warnings, and a personal telephone call from the disaster itself. Please remember that the absence of an emergency alert does not mean there is no emergency. It simply means the emergency has not yet affected anyone the administration gives a shit about. Thank you for your continued cooperation. FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY We can’t save everybody. Frankly, we think that’s an unreasonable expectation for anybody to have. PLEASE RETURN TO YOUR REGULARLY SCHEDULED NATIONAL COLLAPSE. To everyone who supports Closer to the Edge, thank you for keeping our publication alive, helping us expose the bullshit, and proving that while the government may have abandoned its responsibilities, the rest of us haven’t abandoned each other. |
Submitted by Charlotte Lin
By studying people who show no signs of neurodegeneration well into older age, scientists have identified several gene variants that could help to protect against dementia. These protective variants seem to defend the brain against the toxic clusters of proteins that cause Alzheimer’s — mechanisms that scientists now hope to exploit. “Nature has already done the experiment for us: certain gene variants protect us from Alzheimer’s,” says neuroscientist Guojun Bu. “Learning how they do this could guide us to new therapies.”
by David Horsey

We have yet another benchmark for how Donald Trump, rather than making America great again, is doing the opposite: the United States has officially fallen off the list of countries that have eliminated measles.
NOV 13, 2026
I have a bone to pick with whoever is in charge of health care.
My main complaint at the moment concerns my eye drops, one of a variety of prescription medications I take to compensate for the fact that, as I age, my body is deteriorating like a corn dog in a hot dumpster.
I take multiple prescription medications because I have multiple doctors, more doctors than would legally fit into a standard hotel elevator. These doctors are specialists, which means they focus, laser-like, on one specific part of my body, to the exclusion of the remainder of my body. Like, if I had an appointment to see my kidney doctor, and for some reason I happened to have a hatchet embedded in my skull, it’s possible that the kidney doctor, busily entering kidney-related data into the computer, would not notice it. Or if he did, he’d tell me I should make an appointment to see a hatchet-wound specialist, lest my skull become infected, which could affect my kidneys.
(Note that I have just the one doctor caring for both of my kidneys. American doctors do not specialize in just the left or right kidney. Yet.)
When I was a youth growing up in Armonk, N.Y., 237 years ago, there were no medical specialists, at least not that I was aware of. The Armonk healthcare system consisted of Dr. Mortimer “Monty” Cohn, who had an office in a little house on Main Street (really) with a small waiting room containing a tropical-fish tank and a nurse/receptionist named Mrs. See, who was a nice lady, although she once physically prevented me from running out of the building to avoid getting a tetanus shot. Mrs. See was quicker than she looked.
Dr. Cohn did not specialize. He did everything. He delivered all four of us Barry children, and he tended to all of our subsequent medical needs, including broken bones and tonsilitis, which I got on a weekly basis. I never needed brain surgery, but If I had, I believe Dr. Cohn would have performed the operation himself — possibly in my bedroom, because he made house calls — and he’d have charged my parents $12.50, if he even remembered to give them a bill. Also back then gasoline cost 23 cents a gallon, and when you called a business you always talked to a live human being, and the music we listened to had real melodies and lyrics you could actually understa-
Ouch! Sorry! I was starting to launch into a Boomer nostalgia rant there. Fortunately I was stopped by my Boomer Buzzer™, which is a modified dog-training collar that my children had me fitted for when I turned 75. It uses AI to monitor my speech, and when it detects that I’m starting to spew old-fartisms, it administers a brief and usually survivable 10,000-volt electrical shock. Here it is in action:

But getting back to health care: My point is that it used to involve way fewer doctors. Also there were nowhere near as many “scans,” which are costly but vital diagnostic tools that modern medicine uses to determine whether you, the patient, are going to need more scans (yes).
There are two main kinds of scans:
— The kind where you lie on a bed in a darkened room and a person you have never met slathers your skin with a warm lubricant, then aggressively and repeatedly wands your body, sometimes getting perilously close to third base, then abruptly leaves the room and never sends you so much as a heart emoji, let alone flowers.
— The kind where you lie on your back on a hard medical slab and are slid into a claustrophobia-inducing metal tube, and once you’re trapped inside and can’t see what’s happening, large angry men pound on the outside of the tube with baseball bats for 25 solid minutes while a medical technician advises you through headphones to “breathe normally.”
These scans produce images of the inside of your body, which your doctors insist on reviewing with you, which is not unlike showing a diagram of a Toyota Celica transmission to a Labrador retriever, because you did not attend medical school and consequently you have no earthly idea what you’re looking it. My doctors are always showing me inscrutable images like this:

The doctors will point at some random blob of gray amidst all the other gray blobs and say something like, “As you can see, Dave, there’s some turgidity around your anterior postcollateral plectrum valve.” I always nod in a thoughtful manner, but the truth is I can never see what the doctor is talking about. There’s never anything in the image that a layperson would recognize as a clear-cut medical problem, such as:

Don’t get me wrong: I love my doctors, all 53 of them, and I appreciate all that they do for me and my various organs. The healthcare bone I want to pick today, as I stated earlier, involves my eye drops. These were prescribed by my ophthalmologist to reduce the fluid pressure inside my eyes, which is a bit too high, as you can see in this medical scan of my right eyeball:

(Full disclosure: That is not, in fact, a medical scan of my right eyeball. It’s a photograph of Jupiter taken in 1994 from the Hubble Space Telescope. As if you could tell the difference.)
The key ingredient of my eye drops is a chemical compound called “bimatoprost,” which, judging by how much it costs, is a mixture of Dom Perignon, plutonium and unicorn semen. It comes in a small plastic bottle, shown below, from which I’m supposed to squeeze one drop into each eyeball every night at bedtime:

The problem — and now we are getting to the heart of the bone I am picking with our healthcare system — is that when I say the bottle is small, I mean it is tiny. The image above is misleading. To help you visualize the actual size of my bimatoprost bottle, here it is next to a standard raisin and a fruit fly:

So we’re talking about a teensy bottle. And it isn’t even full when I get it from the drugstore. According to the label, it contains 2.5 ml. of bimatoprost. As an American and a patriot I of course have no idea how much “2.5 ml.” is, but I can tell you what it’s not: It’s not enough to enable me to put one drop into every single one of my eyeballs every single night for an entire month, which is how long this bottle is supposed to last.
So I live in constant fear of exhausting my bimatoprost supply. Every night at bedtime as, with shaking hands, I try to maneuver the virtually invisible squirt tip of this minuscule bottle over my eyes, trying desperately not to blink and thereby cause a king’s ransom in bimatoprost to dribble uselessly onto my eyelid, I wonder: Is this the night I run out? What happens to my eye pressure then? WILL MY EYEBALLS EXPLODE?
So this is my plea to whoever is in charge of the U.S. healthcare system: Please do something about this. Like, for starters, put more bimatoprost in the bottle. Also make the bottle bigger. Also make the writing on the bottle bigger. In fact — I speak for my generation here — make the writing on everything bigger. Especially restaurant menus. Also please make the restaurant bright enough that we can read the menus without having to turn on our iPhone flashlights and hunch over and squint at the entrees like Mole People from the Planet AARP. And for the love of God TURN DOWN THE MUSIC IN THE RESTAURANT BECAUSE WE CAN’T EVEN HEAR OURSELVES THINK, LET ALONE HAVE A CONVERSA-

Ed note: Would love to hear your comments!
From Slate: In a three-minute digital short titled “Sister,” Mulaney and others stage a mock pharmaceutical ad for a product to help care for your elderly parents. To the camera, Mulaney says that he loves his aging father who needs care, but he “didn’t want to put him in a nursing home,” and “a private health aide could cost thousands a week.” The solution? Sister, “a live-in, 24/7 eldercare provider that is completely free, and also your sister.” Andrew Dismukes then comes in and states that he doesn’t want to help his aging mother in the bathroom, and “Sister doesn’t either, but she will, whereas I won’t.” Getting the service is easy, Mulaney jokes: “Simply text ‘dad fell’ to Sister and she will quit her job, break her lease, and move halfway across the country to take care of him.” The service works due to “years of internalized sexism” that “warped Sister’s brain into thinking caretaking is her responsibility, and somehow not yours.” Kenan Thompson also explains how it comes at no cost or harm to the men of the family and their financial prospects: “Since your parents’ will predates their dementia, using Sister won’t change your inheritance. You’ll still get 50 percent of the house she’s currently deep-cleaning.”
The skit (apparently written by Mikey Day and Streeter Seidell, surprisingly two men) is pitch-perfect down to each detail. At one point, Mulaney says that not only will she talk to insurance companies and other players in adult care over the phone, but she will be “talked to by Dad,” before it cuts to their father making a comment about her weight. Mulaney also comments that Sister helped him get closer to his father by giving them “something to bond over” during his “infrequent visits.” That thing is, of course, criticizing Sister.
To so specifically poke fun at an accepted gender dynamic of life that we all know to be true, but do not interrogate enough societally, is brutal and entertaining in equal measure. (This remains true even if it does not necessarily apply in every single case: A discussion on Slate Slack revealed that, occasionally, Sister is Brother.) As the eldest child and a Sister myself, I have often found myself bracing for this future reality, one that has also been brought to light in movies like American Fiction. But the existence of “Sister” as a three-minute pill on SNL also proves that the weaponized incompetence of men is just that. Men—or, at least Day and Seidell—are noticing this dynamic, and the fact that we all laugh at it as hard as we do, in the incredulous way that many of us likely responded to the skit, shows that many of the rest of us have noticed it too. Whether any of these brothers care enough to change it may be a different story.
Thanks top Mary Montgomery
FIRST HILL COMMUNITY NEWS
November 2026
Annual Public Safety Survey Open through November 30
This survey, conducted annually by Seattle University in partnership with the Seattle Police Department (SPD), is a key part of Seattle’s Micro-Community Policing Plans (MCPPs)—a program that helps tailor public safety strategies to the unique needs and concerns of each neighborhood, including First Hill.
These plans combine community input with crime data to guide SPD’s focus in ways that reflect what matters most to each community. The survey results help identify local issues, track progress, and adjust strategies based on what residents and workers share about their experiences and perceptions of safety. You can see the 2025 survey results here.
Your feedback shapes how public safety is approached on First Hill—helping ensure that community voices, not just crime statistics, drive neighborhood priorities. Please take the survey by November 30th .Take the Survey
Lighting up First Hill’s Dark Spots
Now that we’ve fallen back and the Seattle sun is setting early, one of FHIA’s priorities is to help make our neighborhood safer by ensuring areas are well-lit (like the sidewalk pictured above by O’Dea High School).
We need your help identifying dark spots around First Hill! These could be intersections, sidewalks, alleys or open spaces – anywhere that a person may walk on First Hill at night that needs more light. Maybe you’ve noticed where existing lights on the side of a building would help, but aren’t working. We want to know all the spots!
Once your input is received, our Clean, Healthy, Safe Committee will walk the neighborhood and map out areas that need attention. Based on what we compile, we’ll work to develop a plan to get spaces better lit and feeling safer. Interested in this project? Sign-up to help on the Clean, Healthy, Safe Committee.
If you’ve noticed a dark spot in the neighborhood, please let us know using the link below. Thank you for sharing! Report Dark Spots
Light Rail Comment Period Opening Soon
Sound Transit is scheduled to release its Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) for the Ballard Link Extension on December 11th. Then there will be a 60-day comment period, providing opportunity for the public to give input that can shape the project.
What is a draft EIS? Sound Transit explains: A draft EIS is an environmental review document that evaluates possible routes and station locations, collectively called “alternatives.” It describes the potential benefits of each alternative and identifies ways to reduce potential impacts.
FHIA’s Transportation Committee will be reviewing the document and preparing comments to help ensure the alternatives serve First Hill. Interested in helping? Sign-up to join Transportation Committee meetings and keep an eye out for advocacy alerts with opportunities to make our voices heard.
Historic Preservation: The Fight ContinuesOn November 9, the U.S. Senate voted to advance the American Affordability and Jobs Act (S. 5653), which includes proposed changes that could weaken the National Historic Preservation Act, particularly Section 106.
Section 106 gives communities, the public, and Tribal Nations a voice when federally funded or approved projects may affect historic places. Weakening these protections could limit opportunities for public input and put important cultural resources at risk. Learn more by watching this video and reading more on the Washington Trust’s blog.
FHIA joins our friends at Historic Seattle and the Washington Trust for Historic Preservation in following this issue closely. Protecting the places that tell our stories and connect us to our shared history matters. Stay tuned—we’ll be sure to share opportunities to raise our voices together in support of historic preservation.
Anderson’s Celebrates 43 Years
There’s something especially comforting about a local business that knows its community and has been here for generations of customers. Anderson’s Comfort Footwear (1012 Madison) has been helping people find comfortable, well-fitting shoes since 1983, and this longtime neighborhood favorite is celebrating with a special anniversary sale – through November 16th, take advantage of these specials: 20% off shoes and 25% off handmade orthotics!
Owner Mickell Baccas has been in the shoe business since 1977, bringing years of experience and a personal touch to helping customers find just the right fit. Whether you’re looking for a great pair of everyday shoes or handmade orthotics for extra support, Mike and team work to ensure “happy feet where feet hit the street.”
Shop the anniversary sale this week to support First Hill’s economy and help celebrate Anderson’s decades of work in our community!
Elementary School Coming to First Hill
Maybe you’ve noticed the colorful window clings along Madison Street between Boylston and Summit? They’re a preview of something exciting: Spruce Street School is coming to First Hill, with plans to open in the summer of 2028!
In 2019, Spruce Street School purchased the building on Madison. Over the last 18 months they have been developing plans to transform the space into their Forever Home on First Hill. Yay! Renovations are expected to begin this spring, including the build out of an outdoor play area on the roof.
Founded in 1982, Spruce Street School is an independent elementary school currently located downtown, with about 100 students in kindergarten through fifth grade. Their small, multi-age classes offer personalized, hands-on learning rooted in curiosity and collaboration, with the city itself serving as an extension of the classroom.
Not only is the school excited to be an active and engaged part of the community, First Hill also very much looks forward to welcoming Spruce Street School families to the neighborhood!
ST. JAMES ADVENT BAZAAR- November 29th | 9am to noon –
Start your holiday shopping at the St. James Cathedral’s Advent Bazaar this year on Sunday, November 29th from 9am-noon in Cathedral Hall (910 Columbia Street). The annual Advent Bazaar features the work of Cathedral artists and friends. Learn more here.New Little Free Libraries Tour Date: November 23rd
Time: 1pm
Location: Starting from The Memory Hub (1021 Columbia)
Grab a friend and join us to visit three NEW Little Free Libraries around First Hill. With help from our friends at Mortenson Construction (who are building the Swedish tower) and Stone Soup Gardens, these new libraries are currently being installed and will be ready for book sharing soon!
Join us to do a quick (15-20 minute) walk to check out these new additions to our neighborhood. We will end at The Baroness Hotel for a reception (including free snacks and refreshments) to celebrate. Feel free to bring a book to share, and sign-up below so we have enough snacks and drinks for all.RSVP HereFirst Hill Food Drive Returns! Date: Through November 30th
Location: A Pizza Mart (800 Seneca St)
Looking for a way to give back this holiday season? Look no further – the First Hill Food Drive is returning this month! We are partnering with A Pizza Mart to support the community by collecting items for local food pantries! Bring tasty non-perishable items to A Pizza Mart through the end of November to get involved. Food items you can donate include:PastaOatmeal and breakfast cerealRice and other grainsSalsa, peanut butter, shelf stable dipsCanned food (fruits, veggies, beans, tuna, etc.)Snacks (granola bars, fruit cups, crackers, etc.)Breakfast items (cereal, Pop-Tarts)Any other shelf-stable items you think others would enjoy!Thank you for your help caring for one another!First Hill Final Friday Date: November 27th
Time: 5:00-7:00 PM
Location: The Hideout (1005 Boren Ave.)
What to do on Black Friday….? Bring your friends and join neighbors and colleagues from 5pm to 7pm on the last Friday in November for socializing and to support a local, First Hill establishment. This month we’re meeting at The Hideout to enjoy delicious, top-notch cocktails and their fabulous art walls. Enjoyfine friends, food, and fun! See you on the final Friday of the month. More Upcoming Events
Click on the events below for details:
November 14 – Small Frye: Story Time & Art at The Frye
November 14 – Jazz Show at Seattle First Baptist
November 18 – Historic Talk at the Mansion
November 19 – Murder Mystery Dinner at Sorrento
November 19 – Secret Concert at the Mansion
November 23 – Little Free Libraries Tour
November 26 – Thanksgiving at Hotel Sorrento
November 27 – First Hill Friday at The Hideout
November 29 – Advent Bazaar at St. James
~ Click the button below to check out more events happening on First Hill ~
PRO TIP: Click “Google Calendar ICS” on event listings to add events directly from our calendar to yours!NEIGHBORHOOD EVENT CALENDAR
Hello Friends,
Last Tuesday’s election demonstrated that people across the nation agreed that the country is moving in the wrong direction. The people have spoken decisively, indicating the need for immediate relief of bread and butter issues: food, housing and health care. There is so much more to be restored, but the people’s needs are first.
We rejoice at the election outcome and presently are suspending gatherings at 8 and Madison. Rather, we propose writing to representatives across the country, encouraging them to pass legislation that moves along their promised agenda. At a recent Town Hall presentation Pramila Jayapal surprised her supporters, stating that legislators profit from their constituents’ communications, even on issues where it’s clear they agree. Knowing that a good percentage of people are on your side is powerful.
PLEASE LET ME KNOW OF YOUR INTEREST IN A WRITING CAMPAIGN.
Judy Mayotte
Seniors at the Crossroads Committee
| Paul Offit Nov 9 (Thanks to Ed Marcuse) |
After RFK Jr. was confirmed as Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), he said that Americans had lost faith in public health agencies during the COVID pandemic. As the nation’s #1 health official, he promised to restore that faith.
In December 2020, COVID vaccines were available to help prevent a disease that was killing thousands of people every day. Most people rushed to get them. But not everyone. About one-third of the American public refused the vaccine. They didn’t think the disease was that bad or they feared that the vaccine was unsafe. Either way, they didn’t want to get vaccinated. RFK Jr. was right there with them. As the head of a virulent anti-vaccine group called Children’s Health Defense, he had been an anti-vaccine activist for more than 20 years. When the COVID vaccine became available, he testified in front of the Louisiana state legislature that it was “the deadliest vaccine ever made,” and argued that vaccines shouldn’t be mandated. The medical freedom movement was born.
As Secretary of HHS, RFK Jr. tried to regain the public’s trust—or at least the minority of the public that rejected vaccines—by dismantling the vaccine infrastructure. He fired all 17 members of the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), replacing them with people who, like him, thought vaccines were unnecessarily harmful. He reduced the number of routinely recommended vaccines from 17-11. He said that HHS would no longer recommend COVID vaccines for healthy children and pregnant women. In response to RFK Jr.’s agenda, public trust in federal health agencies declined even further from 77% to 50%.
Then RFK Jr.’s quest to restore public trust took another dangerous turn. “If you want to take an experimental drug,” he said, “you ought to be able to do that. We want to respect the intelligence of the American public to decide what treatments will benefit them the most.” RFK Jr. warned the FDA not to “tell physicians what they can and can’t prescribe.”
True to his word, RFK Jr. forced the FDA to remove warnings about bogus cures for autism, such as stem cells, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, and chelation. He was particularly enamored with stem cells, which he claimed had treated his voice disorder but was angry that he had to travel to Antigua to get them. Children, argued Kennedy Jr., should be able to use stem cells to treat autism even though the procedure costs $20,000, involves sedating the child with ketamine, and has been shown by Duke University researchers not to work.
RFK Jr. also 1) forced the FDA to take down it’s warnings about testosterone, 2) replaced an FDA advisory committee with members of the peptide industry so he could eliminate restrictions on peptides that were unproven or unsafe, and 3) manipulated the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee so that he could promote saturated fats over unsaturated fats in clear contradiction of the American Heart Association’s warnings that saturated fats increase the risk of heart disease—a fact supported by more than four dozen studies.
RFK Jr. was a perfect example of the 19th century German philosopher Georg Hegel’s warning that, “What we learn from history is that we don’t learn from history.” The United States has for decades benefited from federal oversight of drugs and biologicals, most notably in 1957 when the FDA refused to license thalidomide, a sleeping pill made by the German company Chemie Grünenthal because safety studies in pregnant women were lacking. Thalidomide use in other countries damaged 24,000 embryos, more than half of whom died before birth. According to RFK Jr.’s philosophy, the FDA shouldn’t have restricted thalidomide. Rather, it should have “respected the intelligence of the American public” to make their own decisions.
In RFK Jr.’s America, medical freedom has become freedom from federal regulation of drugs, foods, biologicals, and vaccines. The consequences, as forewarned by Hegel, are entirely predictable.
Thanks to Mary Jane Francis
We need more books! Please donate now in the Mt. Baker Room by Thursday!
from Betsy Hansen
The Library Committee is looking for more books. Do you have a stack of books by your bed that you’ve read and want to get rid of? Have you just recently joined us here at Skyline and found that you’ve brought too many with you? You can donate them to our annual collection for the Great Book Giveaway this Friday, November 13. Place your books and DVDs in the box in the corner of the Mount Baker room by November 11. We will scan them for those to be kept for our library before the event.
Ideas matter most when they’re paired with moral clarity — from IN PURSUIT
Before Ronald Reagan’s “Morning in America,” the nation endured a long and difficult twilight. By the mid-1970s, America was experiencing overlapping economic, social, and foreign policy crises. The unemployment rate hit 9 percent in May of 1975 and inflation reached 15 percent by 1980. Between 1960 and 1980, divorce rates doubled, violent crime rates nearly tripled, and drug use exploded. The Soviet Union—far from the weak and doomed enterprise it appears in retrospect—had made communists gains from Cambodia to Angola. In 1964, 78 percent of Americans reported that they trusted government to do the right thing. By 1980, after Vietnam, Watergate, and deteriorating conditions at home, only 26 percent of voters said that. In 1979 Jimmy Carter delivered his notorious malaise speech, in which he described an American “crisis of confidence…threatening to destroy the social and political fabric of America.”
By the end of Reagan’s first term, America looked and felt very different. American society had gradually begun to shift to the right, with Congress cutting taxes and deregulating the airline and trucking industries. Reagan won re-election by one of the biggest landslide majorities in history. From 1982 to 1990 the American economy grew by about 4 percent a year. By the time he left office in 1988, Reagan’s approval rating stood at 63 percent. The Berlin wall fell a year later.
How did Reagan lead the country out of hard times and rekindle Americans’ faith in themselves? What made Reagan such a successful president?
This is not an easy question to answer. As the conservative writer Christopher Caldwell put it: “Even those who count Ronald Reagan among the handful of great American presidents have a hard time saying exactly where his greatness lay, or how it made itself felt. Reagan was an enigma: affable but friendless, a nonintellectual man of ideas, an ingenuous power politician.” Out of the riddle of Reagan, however, one lesson emerges clearly: that ideas matter most when they’re paired with moral clarity.
President Reagan grabbing handful of jellybeans with Alexander Haig and Richard Allen during a meeting with Interagency Working Committee on Terrorism in the Cabinet Room. January 26, 1981. Ronald Reagan Presidential Library & Museum.
One of the keys to Reagan’s success, paradoxically, was that he was old. When he entered the White House at age 69, he was six years older than FDR was when he died in office. Reagan was born in 1911, chronologically closer to Thomas Jefferson’s presidency than to Donald Trump’s. He was formed in an earlier age, before many of the ideological currents that rocked the 20th century. (continued on page 2)
from “Now That Makes Sense” a compilation by Mark Ortman
Happiness is a by-product of an effort to make someone else happy. — Greta Palmer
One of the deepest secrets of life is that all that is really worth doing is what we do for others. — Lewis Carroll
Gratitude takes three forms: a feeling in the heart, an expression in words, and a giving in return. — Anonymous
The President’s unique brand of lurid authoritarianism has finally lost appeal, and he has lost the plot.
David Remnick, The New Yorker Editor (submitted by Charlotte Lin)
Two generations ago, in the fall of 1974, President Gerald Ford and the Republican Party approached the midterm elections with considerable dread. That August, Richard Nixon had learned that he could no longer outrun his crimes in the White House. One tape recording in particular, the so-called smoking gun, proved that he had conspired with his aide H. R. Haldeman to obstruct the investigation into the Watergate break-in. The Republican elders Barry Goldwater, John Rhodes, and Hugh Scott told Nixon that impeachment in the House of Representatives was now certain, and conviction in the Senate likely. Nixon resigned, handing over his office to Vice-President Ford. A month later, Ford issued Proclamation 4311, pardoning Nixon for any crimes that he might have committed as President. Watergate, Ford said, had been “an American tragedy, in which we all have played a part. It could go on and on and on, or someone must write the end to it. I have concluded that only I can do that, and if I can, I must.”
Until then, despite a dreadful economy, Ford had enjoyed approval ratings as high as seventy per cent. But the Nixon pardon was political poison, for both Ford and the G.O.P. His popularity plummeted by more than twenty points. And, in the midterms, the Democrats gained forty-nine seats in the House and four seats in the Senate. The incoming class of rookie Democrats—among them Gary Hart, Paul Tsongas, John Glenn, and Patrick Leahy—became known as the “Watergate babies.”
This week, some commentators, having exhausted the usual marine metaphors for midterm blowouts (a “blue wave” quickly became a “blue tsunami”), scurried to find historical points of comparison for the astonishing nationwide triumph of the Democratic Party. More than a few settled on the post-pardon midterms of 1974. (continued on page 2)